AI SEO Tools Benchmark, edition 1
Siftly in the AI SEO Tools Benchmark
Tracks brand mentions and cited sources in AI answers, starting with ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews and adding engines on higher plans. Not for teams that need Claude on a self-serve plan; Claude appears only on the custom-priced Enterprise plan.
Siftly, edition 1
- Category
- AI visibility tracking
- Status
- Live
- Website
- siftly.ai
- Measured
- 1,199 answers, collected on 16 October 2026 (India time); one of them a ChatGPT test answer from 13 October
- Asked from
- United States, in English
- Accuracy
- Listed, not yet accuracy-tested
- Written by
- Chandan Bakshi, Founder, SEO Informatica Labs
How often AI answers named Siftly
We asked the same 25 buyer questions on four surfaces. A rate counts the answers that named Siftly, out of every answer on that surface. It is a mention rate over these runs, not a rank in AI.
- ChatGPT
- 0%: named in 0 of 750 answersNamed in answers to 0 of 25 questions. Its own site cited in 7 of 750.
- Perplexity
- 6%: named in 23 of 400 answersNamed in answers to 3 of 25 questions. Its own site cited in 64 of 400.
- Google AI Overviews
- 0%: named in 0 of 24 overviewsNamed in answers to 0 of 25 questions. Its own site cited in 1 of 24.
- Google AI Mode
- 0%: named in 0 of 25 answersNamed in answers to 0 of 25 questions. Its own site cited in 0 of 25.
Price, plan and free option
The lowest published plan, as the vendor's own page showed it on the date below. Prices change; follow the source before you buy.
- Starting price
- $79 a monthStarter plan. Annual billing saves 20%. 50 prompts, 4,500 responses a month, 3 engines, 1 geography, daily refresh, 1 seat
- Free option
- Free plan. Free plan: 10 prompts, 2 engines, weekly refresh, 1 seat. Paid plans have a 7-day trial, no card.
- Verified
- Verified on 16 October 2026, at siftly.ai/pricing
- How it was read
- Read twice: a second reader checked the same pages and corrected the first reading.
- Our reading of the vendor's prices and limits, on 16 October 2026
- Free $0: 10 prompts, 100 responses a month, 2 engines, weekly refresh, 1 seat. Starter $79/mo: 50 prompts, 4,500 responses, 3 engines, 1 geography, daily, 1 seat. Growth $249/mo: 100 prompts, 30,000 responses, 5 engines, 2 geographies, 3 seats. Scale $599/mo: 150 prompts, 108,000 responses, 8 engines, 3 geographies, 5 seats. Enterprise custom. Annual billing saves 20%.
Engines tracked
The AI engines the vendor says the product tracks, on at least one plan, as its own pages stated them.
- Engines
- ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode, Gemini, Claude, Microsoft Copilot, Grok, DeepSeek
- Per plan, as we read the vendor's pages
- Pricing comparison table: Free = ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews; Starter adds Perplexity; Growth adds Gemini and Google AI Mode; Scale adds Copilot, Grok and DeepSeek; Claude appears only on the Enterprise card. Plan card icons omit AI Mode, and a nav blurb mentions 4 engines; these read as display shortcuts, not a different engine set. Source
Status and ownership
Live.
Free checker
Agrees with the measured rates.
- Checker
- Free AI Visibility Checker (live answers)
- Verdict
- Agrees with the measured rates: 3 of 3 tests passed
- Mean gap from our measured rates
- 14.1 points
- The control, SEO Informatica
- 0, low (no mistake: control scored low)
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | Dominant | 93.0 | 78.1% | 14.9 |
| Otterly | Dominant | 69.0 | 61.6% | 7.4 |
| Ahrefs | Dominant | 80.0 | 61.7% | 18.3 |
| Profound | Emerging | 31.0 | 58.5% | -27.5 |
| Peec AI | Strong | 36.0 | 52.8% | -16.8 |
| SEO Informatica | Not visible. No mentions detected across any AI platform. | 0.0 | 0.0% | 0.0 |
What it is for, and not for
From the vendor's own pages, read on 16 October 2026. A prompt is a question a tool asks AI engines for you; a citation is a link to a site among an answer's sources; an API is a way for your own software to pull a tool's data.
- For
- Tracks brand mentions and cited sources in AI answers, starting with ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews and adding engines on higher plans.
- Not for
- Not for teams that need Claude on a self-serve plan; Claude appears only on the custom-priced Enterprise plan.
- Source
- siftly.ai/pricing
Scorecard
The openness score rates what a vendor publishes about its product (engines, method, price, data freshness, exports), not how good the product is.
- Openness score
- 52.5 of 60
- Accuracy and setup time
- Accuracy (30) and setup time (10): pending access. Listed, not yet accuracy-tested.
- Coverage
- 15 of 15: which AI engines it tracks, and on which plans
- Transparency
- 7.5 of 15: disclosed run counts and sampling, and whether the models and the surface (app or API) are named
- Price
- 15 of 15: a published starting price with plan limits, and a free tier
- Freshness
- 10 of 10: how often the data updates
- Exports
- 5 of 5: data exports and a documented API
Every fact behind the score, with its page
- Starting price and plan limits: level 1
- Free $0: 10 prompts, 100 responses a month, 2 engines, weekly refresh, 1 seat. Starter $79/mo: 50 prompts, 4,500 responses, 3 engines, 1 geography, daily, 1 seat. Growth $249/mo: 100 prompts, 30,000 responses, 5 engines, 2 geographies, 3 seats. Scale $599/mo: 150 prompts, 108,000 responses, 8 engines, 3 geographies, 5 seats. Enterprise custom. Annual billing saves 20%. SourceConfirmed by a second reading.
- Engines tracked: level 1
- Pricing comparison table: Free = ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews; Starter adds Perplexity; Growth adds Gemini and Google AI Mode; Scale adds Copilot, Grok and DeepSeek; Claude appears only on the Enterprise card. Plan card icons omit AI Mode, and a nav blurb mentions 4 engines; these read as display shortcuts, not a different engine set. SourceConfirmed by a second reading.
- Disclosed run counts and sampling: level 0.5
- Pricing (https://siftly.ai/pricing) defines a response as one AI answer to one tracked prompt on one engine per refresh. The plan quotas work out to exactly one run per prompt per engine per geography per day, for example Starter 50 prompts x 3 engines x 30 days = 4,500. The ChatGPT visibility page instead says each prompt runs many times daily across GPT-4o, GPT-5 and o1, and across conversational and search modes. It reports a mention rate per model with confidence intervals but never gives a sample count. Its FAQ says only 'multiple times a day'. SourceThe first two readings differed; a third reading settled it.
- Model and surface disclosed: level 0.5
- ChatGPT visibility page names GPT-4o, GPT-5, o1 and ChatGPT Search and reports per-model mention rates. No page states whether the paid platform captures the consumer app or calls APIs; the free checker page says the checker itself uses public APIs (gpt-5.4-mini, claude-sonnet-4-6) and only implies the paid platform reaches consumer-UI fidelity. SourceConfirmed by a second reading.
- Data freshness: level 1
- Daily refresh on Starter, Growth and Scale; weekly on Free. Docs also let users schedule daily, weekly (recommended) or monthly analysis. SourceConfirmed by a second reading.
- Exports and API: level 1
- Docs document CSV and PDF export from the Citations page, and a hosted MCP server (https://mcp.siftly.ai/mcp) with setup steps for ChatGPT, Claude, Claude Code and other clients; it needs an active subscription. Homepage claims REST access but no public REST reference was found. SourceConfirmed by a second reading.
- Free tier: level 1
- Free $0 plan (10 prompts, 2 engines, weekly). Free AI Visibility Checker takes a domain, needs no login and shows a score preview; emailing the full report requires a work email on the same domain. Paid plans have a 7-day trial with no card. SourceConfirmed by a second reading.
Each fact gets a level from 0 (not published) to 1 (published in full), and each part of the score is its points times those levels. How the levels and points work.
Read on 16 October 2026.
The Clarity Audit
Want to know who AI names in your market?
The Clarity Audit is free. We look at your website and your market, show which businesses Google and AI answers name for the searches your buyers make, and list the three fixes to consider first. No call needed.