AI SEO Tools Benchmark: free checkers
Do free AI visibility checkers agree with what AI answers say?
Many AI visibility tools offer a free checker that grades a brand. For each tool we tried its main brand checker that needed no account and no email, on the same brands, then compared its verdict with how often our measured answers named those brands.
A verdict here is about the free checker's result, not about the paid product.
The test record
- Free checkers found
- 155 on 52 of the 64 live AI visibility tools
- Tried
- 37 checkers, the main brand checker of each tool that offered one, with the same inputs for every brand
- Brands
- Semrush, Otterly, Ahrefs, Profound and Peec AI, plus SEO Informatica as the control
- Returned a result
- 19 of 37, with no account and no email
- Checked on
- 16 October 2026
- Compared with
- Our measured mention rates on ChatGPT, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews and Google AI Mode
- Written by
- Chandan Bakshi, Founder, SEO Informatica Labs
The measured rates we compared against.
For each brand, the share of our answers that named it on each surface. SEO Informatica is the control: no answer named it, so a checker that rates it well is not measuring these answers.
| Brand | ChatGPT | Perplexity | Google AI Overviews | Google AI Mode |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | 78% (586 of 750 answers) | 88% (352 of 400 answers) | 75% (18 of 24 overviews) | 76% (19 of 25 answers) |
| Otterly | 62% (462 of 750 answers) | 48% (191 of 400 answers) | 46% (11 of 24 overviews) | 48% (12 of 25 answers) |
| Ahrefs | 62% (463 of 750 answers) | 67% (268 of 400 answers) | 58% (14 of 24 overviews) | 56% (14 of 25 answers) |
| Profound | 59% (439 of 750 answers) | 40% (161 of 400 answers) | 50% (12 of 24 overviews) | 52% (13 of 25 answers) |
| Peec AI | 53% (396 of 750 answers) | 34% (136 of 400 answers) | 29% (7 of 24 overviews) | 36% (9 of 25 answers) |
| SEO Informatica (control) | 0% (0 of 750 answers) | 0% (0 of 400 answers) | 0% (0 of 24 overviews) | 0% (0 of 25 answers) |
Which checkers agree, and by how much.
19 of the 37 checkers we tried returned a result. 5 agree with the measured rates on every test that applied, 10 partly agree, 2 disagree, 1 measured something other than visibility and 1 gave too few results to judge.
| Checker | Verdict | Brands with a result | Tests passed | Rank correlation | Control (SEO Informatica) | Mean gap, points | Bands matching |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CitedSpy: AI Visibility Checkerlive answers | Agrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 3 of 3 | 0.78 | 0 (low) | 11.7 | 4 of 6 |
| Gauge: AI Product Rankings (productrank.ai)stored index data | Agrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 2 of 2 | 0.83 | 0 (low) | not judged | 5 of 6 |
| MaxAEO: AI Overview Checkerstored index data | Agrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 2 of 2 | 1.00 | 0 (low) | not judged | 1 of 1 |
| SE Ranking: Free AI visibility check (AI Visibility Tracker page)stored index data | Agrees with the measured rates | 5 of 6 | 2 of 2 | 0.82 | 0 (low) | not judged | 1 of 1 |
| Siftly: Free AI Visibility Checkerlive answers | Agrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 3 of 3 | 0.94 | 0 (low) | 14.1 | 4 of 6 |
| AI Peekaboo: ChatGPT Citation Checkerlive answers | Partly agrees with the measured rates | 3 of 6 | 1 of 2 | not judged | 0 (low) | 23.0 | 3 of 3 |
| Beamtrace: Check AI Visibility for Free (homepage)live answers | Partly agrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 1 of 3 | 0.75 | 20 (not low) | 21.8 | 4 of 6 |
| CITED: Free AI visibility checklive answers | Partly agrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 1 of 3 | 0.70 | 0 (low) | 22.2 | 3 of 6 |
| Geoptie: Free AI Visibility Checkerlive answers | Partly agrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 1 of 3 | 0.67 | 0 (low) | 26.4 | 4 of 6 |
| HubSpot: AI Search Gradermodel knowledge | Partly agrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 2 of 3 | 0.81 | 42 (not low) | 14.8 | 3 of 6 |
| Mentionable: Free AI visibility checklive answers | Partly agrees with the measured rates | 3 of 6 | 1 of 2 | not judged | 0 (low) | 21.4 | 2 of 3 |
| Otterly: AI Authority Checkermodel knowledge | Partly agrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 1 of 3 | 0.77 | 23 (not low) | 22.7 | 2 of 6 |
| RankPrompt: Free AI Visibility Checkermodel knowledge | Partly agrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 1 of 3 | 0.41 | 0 (low) | 35.7 | 3 of 6 |
| Scrunch: Free Brand Auditlive answers | Partly agrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 2 of 3 | 0.83 | 0 (low) | 26.1 | 3 of 6 |
| Trakkr: AI Rank Trackermodel knowledge | Partly agrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 2 of 3 | 0.78 | 0 (low) | 36.1 | 3 of 6 |
| Bloomiro: Free Website Visibility Checkersite readiness | Disagrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 0 of 3 | -0.03 | 83 (not low) | 27.9 | 4 of 6 |
| Botric: Free GEO Audit (AI Visibility Score)site readiness | Disagrees with the measured rates | 6 of 6 | 0 of 3 | -0.03 | 83 (not low) | 26.9 | 4 of 6 |
| Foglift: Free AI Brand Visibility Checkerlive answers | Not a visibility measurement | 6 of 6 | none applied | not judged | not a visibility measurement | not judged | none compared |
| Cituna: AI visibility checker (crawler readiness)site readiness | Too few results to judge | 6 of 6 | 0 of 1 | not judged | high (not low) | not judged | 4 of 6 |
Open a checker to see what it reported for each brand next to our measured rate.
CitedSpy: AI Visibility Checker, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | Strong AI visibility. AI engines reliably surface you in your category and rank you near the top. Defend the lead and keep content fresh. | 78.0 | 77.1% (ChatGPT + Google AI Mode) | 0.9 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | Partial AI visibility. You show up in some answers but not consistently - there are engines and prompts where competitors crowd you out. | 71.0 | 54.8% (ChatGPT + Google AI Mode) | 16.2 | high against high: match |
| Ahrefs | Partial AI visibility. You show up in some answers but not consistently - there are engines and prompts where competitors crowd you out. | 71.0 | 58.9% (ChatGPT + Google AI Mode) | 12.1 | high against high: match |
| Profound | Weak AI visibility. You surface only thinly. Most engines either miss you or rank you below the competitors buyers see first. | 33.0 | 55.3% (ChatGPT + Google AI Mode) | -22.3 | medium against high: differ |
| Peec AI | Partial AI visibility. You show up in some answers but not consistently - there are engines and prompts where competitors crowd you out. | 63.0 | 44.4% (ChatGPT + Google AI Mode) | 18.6 | high against medium: differ |
| SEO Informatica | Largely invisible. AI engines mostly recommend competitors over you in your own category. This is the gap GEO closes - and the biggest opportunity. | 0.0 | 0.0% (ChatGPT + Google AI Mode) | 0.0 | none against none: match |
Gauge: AI Product Rankings (productrank.ai), brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | No verdict wording; page says 'Find topics that Semrush ranks for, according to AI' and lists 161 topics, #1 overall in 50 of them (self-naming prompts removed: score recomputed on the other 160 of 161) | none | 83.1% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | high against high: match | |
| Otterly | No verdict wording; the 'Otterly' record lists 1 topic: 'Ai visibility' at #9 | none | 54.7% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | low against high: differ | |
| Ahrefs | No verdict wording; lists 130 topics, #1 overall in 12 of them | none | 64.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | high against high: match | |
| Profound | No verdict wording; lists 33 topics, #1 overall in 2 of them | none | 49.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | medium against medium: match | |
| Peec AI | No verdict wording; lists 27 topics, #1 overall in 3 of them (self-naming prompts removed: score recomputed on the other 26 of 27) | none | 43.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | medium against medium: match | |
| SEO Informatica | No ranked topics shown; the page 'Find topics that SEO Informatica ranks for, according to AI' has no topic table at all | none | 0.0% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | none against none: match |
MaxAEO: AI Overview Checker, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | 20,479 Keywords where an AI Overview cites semrush.com | none | 75.0% (Google AI Overview) | ||
| Otterly | 40 Keywords where an AI Overview cites otterly.ai | none | 45.8% (Google AI Overview) | ||
| Ahrefs | 5,240 Keywords where an AI Overview cites ahrefs.com | none | 58.3% (Google AI Overview) | ||
| Profound | 233 Keywords where an AI Overview cites tryprofound.com (partly: 2 of 20 shown prompts name the brand, and the checker's score includes them) | none | 50.0% (Google AI Overview) | ||
| Peec AI | 8 Keywords where an AI Overview cites peec.ai (self-naming prompts removed: score recomputed on the other 2 of 8) | none | 29.2% (Google AI Overview) | ||
| SEO Informatica | Google's AI Overviews don't cite seoinformatica.com for any keyword in this index yet. | none | 0.0% (Google AI Overview) | none against none: match |
SE Ranking: Free AI visibility check (AI Visibility Tracker page), brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | No verdict text shown; numbers only (brand mentions and linked mentions per engine) | none | 79.3% (Google AI Overview + Google AI Mode + ChatGPT + Perplexity) | ||
| Otterly | No verdict text shown; numbers only (brand mentions and linked mentions per engine) | none | 50.8% (Google AI Overview + Google AI Mode + ChatGPT + Perplexity) | ||
| Ahrefs | No verdict text shown; numbers only (brand mentions and linked mentions per engine) | none | 60.8% (Google AI Overview + Google AI Mode + ChatGPT + Perplexity) | ||
| Profound | limit reached | none | 50.2% (Google AI Overview + Google AI Mode + ChatGPT + Perplexity) | ||
| Peec AI | No verdict text shown; numbers only (brand mentions and linked mentions per engine) | none | 38.0% (Google AI Overview + Google AI Mode + ChatGPT + Perplexity) | ||
| SEO Informatica | No verdict text shown; table shows 0 brand mentions and 0 linked mentions on all 5 engines | none | 0.0% (Google AI Overview + Google AI Mode + ChatGPT + Perplexity) | none against none: match |
Siftly: Free AI Visibility Checker, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | Dominant | 93.0 | 78.1% (ChatGPT) | 14.9 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | Dominant | 69.0 | 61.6% (ChatGPT) | 7.4 | high against high: match |
| Ahrefs | Dominant | 80.0 | 61.7% (ChatGPT) | 18.3 | high against high: match |
| Profound | Emerging | 31.0 | 58.5% (ChatGPT) | -27.5 | medium against high: differ |
| Peec AI | Strong | 36.0 | 52.8% (ChatGPT) | -16.8 | medium against high: differ |
| SEO Informatica | Not visible. No mentions detected across any AI platform. | 0.0 | 0.0% (ChatGPT) | 0.0 | none against none: match |
AI Peekaboo: ChatGPT Citation Checker, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | Your website is cited | 100.0 | 78.1% (ChatGPT) | 21.9 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | limit reached | none | 61.6% (ChatGPT) | ||
| Ahrefs | limit reached | none | 61.7% (ChatGPT) | ||
| Profound | limit reached | none | 58.5% (ChatGPT) | ||
| Peec AI | Your website is cited | 100.0 | 52.8% (ChatGPT) | 47.2 | high against high: match |
| SEO Informatica | Unable to determine. The available evidence is incomplete. This check cannot establish the full citation status. | 0.0 | 0.0% (ChatGPT) | 0.0 | none against none: match |
Beamtrace: Check AI Visibility for Free (homepage), brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | Your overall AI Visibility Score 90 (gauge band: Leading) (partly: 1 of 5 shown prompts name the brand, and the checker's score includes them) | 90.0 | 79.3% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 10.7 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | Your overall AI Visibility Score 60 (gauge band: Moderate/Strong boundary) (partly: 1 of 5 shown prompts name the brand, and the checker's score includes them) | 60.0 | 50.8% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 9.2 | high against high: match |
| Ahrefs | Your overall AI Visibility Score 90 (gauge band: Leading) (partly: 1 of 5 shown prompts name the brand, and the checker's score includes them) | 90.0 | 60.8% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 29.2 | high against high: match |
| Profound | Your overall AI Visibility Score 70 (gauge band: Strong) (partly: 1 of 5 shown prompts name the brand, and the checker's score includes them) | 70.0 | 50.2% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 19.8 | high against high: match |
| Peec AI | Your overall AI Visibility Score 80 (gauge band: Strong/Leading boundary) (partly: 1 of 5 shown prompts name the brand, and the checker's score includes them) | 80.0 | 38.0% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 42.0 | high against medium: differ |
| SEO Informatica | Your overall AI Visibility Score 20 (gauge band: Invisible/Weak boundary) (partly: 1 of 5 shown prompts name the brand, and the checker's score includes them) | 20.0 | 0.0% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 20.0 | medium against none: differ |
CITED: Free AI visibility check, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | You're showing up strong. | 90.0 | 79.3% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 10.7 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | You're invisible to AI. | 0.0 | 50.8% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | -50.8 | none against high: differ |
| Ahrefs | You're showing up strong. | 80.0 | 60.8% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 19.2 | high against high: match |
| Profound | You're invisible to AI. | 10.0 | 50.2% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | -40.2 | low against high: differ |
| Peec AI | You're on the radar. | 50.0 | 38.0% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 12.0 | high against medium: differ |
| SEO Informatica | You're invisible to AI. | 0.0 | 0.0% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 0.0 | none against none: match |
Geoptie: Free AI Visibility Checker, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | You're winning. Protect your spot. | 96.0 | 83.1% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 12.9 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | You're winning. Protect your spot. | 88.0 | 54.7% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 33.3 | high against high: match |
| Ahrefs | You're winning. Protect your spot. | 100.0 | 64.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 35.6 | high against high: match |
| Profound | You're showing up - but competitors rank higher. | 73.0 | 49.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 23.6 | high against medium: differ |
| Peec AI | You're winning. Protect your spot. | 96.0 | 43.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 52.6 | high against medium: differ |
| SEO Informatica | You're invisible. Start tracking now. (Your brand doesn't show up in AI search results.) | 0.0 | 0.0% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 0.0 | none against none: match |
HubSpot: AI Search Grader, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | This score is great (all three engines) | 78.0 | 83.1% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | -5.1 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | You're on the right track (all three engines) | 51.7 | 54.7% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | -3.0 | high against high: match |
| Ahrefs | This score is great (all three engines) | 78.0 | 64.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 13.6 | high against high: match |
| Profound | OpenAI: You're on the right track; Perplexity: This score is great; Gemini: You're on the right track | 63.3 | 49.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 13.9 | high against medium: differ |
| Peec AI | OpenAI: You're on the right track; Perplexity: This score is great; Gemini: You're on the right track | 54.0 | 43.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 10.6 | high against medium: differ |
| SEO Informatica | OpenAI: This score has room for growth; Perplexity: You're on the right track; Gemini: You're on the right track | 42.3 | 0.0% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 42.3 | medium against none: differ |
Mentionable: Free AI visibility check, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | Semrush is cited in 2 of 3 ChatGPT answers | 66.7 | 78.1% (ChatGPT) | -11.4 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | limit reached | none | 61.6% (ChatGPT) | ||
| Ahrefs | limit reached | none | 61.7% (ChatGPT) | ||
| Profound | limit reached | none | 58.5% (ChatGPT) | ||
| Peec AI | ChatGPT doesn't mention Peec AI | 0.0 | 52.8% (ChatGPT) | -52.8 | none against high: differ |
| SEO Informatica | ChatGPT doesn't mention SEO Informatica | 0.0 | 0.0% (ChatGPT) | 0.0 | none against none: match |
Otterly: AI Authority Checker, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | Known Entity, Well Known | 78.0 | 78.1% (ChatGPT) | -0.1 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | Low Visibility, Niche Brand | 26.0 | 61.6% (ChatGPT) | -35.6 | medium against high: differ |
| Ahrefs | Known Entity, Well Known | 80.0 | 61.7% (ChatGPT) | 18.3 | high against high: match |
| Profound | Low Visibility, Niche Brand | 25.0 | 58.5% (ChatGPT) | -33.5 | medium against high: differ |
| Peec AI | Low Visibility, Niche Brand | 27.0 | 52.8% (ChatGPT) | -25.8 | medium against high: differ |
| SEO Informatica | Low Visibility, Niche Brand | 23.0 | 0.0% (ChatGPT) | 23.0 | medium against none: differ |
RankPrompt: Free AI Visibility Checker, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | 3 of 3 assistants would likely name your brand. | 100.0 | 83.1% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 16.9 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | 0 of 3 assistants would likely name your brand. | 0.0 | 54.7% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | -54.7 | none against high: differ |
| Ahrefs | 3 of 3 assistants would likely name your brand. | 100.0 | 64.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 35.6 | high against high: match |
| Profound | 3 of 3 assistants would likely name your brand. | 100.0 | 49.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 50.6 | high against medium: differ |
| Peec AI | 3 of 3 assistants would likely name your brand. | 100.0 | 43.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 56.6 | high against medium: differ |
| SEO Informatica | 0 of 3 assistants would likely name your brand. | 0.0 | 0.0% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 0.0 | none against none: match |
Scrunch: Free Brand Audit, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | Good | 60.0 | 83.1% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | -23.1 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | Very Poor | 10.0 | 54.7% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | -44.7 | low against high: differ |
| Ahrefs | Poor | 32.0 | 64.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | -32.4 | medium against high: differ |
| Profound | Very Poor | 8.0 | 49.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | -41.4 | low against medium: differ |
| Peec AI | Poor | 28.0 | 43.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | -15.4 | medium against medium: match |
| SEO Informatica | Very Poor | 0.0 | 0.0% (ChatGPT + Perplexity) | 0.0 | none against none: match |
Trakkr: AI Rank Tracker, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | Semrush ranks #1 in four of seven SEO probes but is absent from the AI visibility tracking question, where Brandwatch wins. (self-naming prompts removed: score recomputed on the other 6 of 7) | 83.3 | 78.1% (ChatGPT) | 5.2 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | Otterly.ai is absent from all eight high-intent AI-visibility questions, and the model's prior on the brand itself is blank or confused with Otter.ai; SEMrush wins the category answer. (self-naming prompts removed: score recomputed on the other 6 of 8) | 0.0 | 61.6% (ChatGPT) | -61.6 | none against high: differ |
| Ahrefs | Ahrefs leads most high-intent SEO questions but loses the AI-search visibility question to Semrush, which is named first while Ahrefs is framed only as a backlink tool. (self-naming prompts removed: score recomputed on the other 6 of 7) | 100.0 | 61.7% (ChatGPT) | 38.3 | high against high: match |
| Profound | Profound is absent from all seven cold buyer probes, including the direct alternatives query, where the model misreads the name and names Algolia, ElasticSearch, and Swiftype instead. (self-naming prompts removed: score recomputed on the other 6 of 7) | 0.0 | 58.5% (ChatGPT) | -58.5 | none against high: differ |
| Peec AI | Peec AI is absent from all seven buyer questions and is not recognized by name; legacy SEO suites like SEMrush and Ahrefs win every category query. (self-naming prompts removed: score recomputed on the other 6 of 7) | 0.0 | 52.8% (ChatGPT) | -52.8 | none against high: differ |
| SEO Informatica | SEO Informatica is absent from all seven probed buyer questions, including the one naming it directly; WebFX and Ignite Visibility win the B2B agency question. (self-naming prompts removed: score recomputed on the other 6 of 7) | 0.0 | 0.0% (ChatGPT) | 0.0 | none against none: match |
Bloomiro: Free Website Visibility Checker, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | 4/4 readiness checks passed | 77.0 | 79.3% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | -2.3 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | 3/4 readiness checks passed (Content Structure Needs work) | 80.0 | 50.8% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 29.2 | high against high: match |
| Ahrefs | 4/4 readiness checks passed | 74.0 | 60.8% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 13.2 | high against high: match |
| Profound | 3/4 readiness checks passed (Can AI Read You? Needs work) | 65.0 | 50.2% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 14.8 | high against high: match |
| Peec AI | 3/4 readiness checks passed (Can AI Read You? Needs work) | 63.0 | 38.0% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 25.0 | high against medium: differ |
| SEO Informatica | 4/4 readiness checks passed | 83.0 | 0.0% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | 83.0 | high against none: differ |
Botric: Free GEO Audit (AI Visibility Score), brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | GOOD. Coverage is uneven. Targeted fixes close the gap fast. | 69.0 | 80.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity + Google AI Overview) | -11.4 | high against high: match |
| Otterly | CRITICAL. AI engines are missing key signals. Fix these to get found. | 0.0 | 50.8% (mean of the 4 measured engines) | -50.8 | none against high: differ |
| Ahrefs | FOUNDATION. Coverage is uneven. Targeted fixes close the gap fast. | 55.0 | 62.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity + Google AI Overview) | -7.4 | high against high: match |
| Profound | FOUNDATION. AI engines are missing key signals. Fix these to get found. | 46.0 | 49.6% (ChatGPT + Perplexity + Google AI Overview) | -3.6 | medium against medium: match |
| Peec AI | FOUNDATION. AI engines are missing key signals. Fix these to get found. | 44.0 | 38.7% (ChatGPT + Perplexity + Google AI Overview) | 5.3 | medium against medium: match |
| SEO Informatica | GOOD. You're ahead, sharpen a few areas to widen the lead. | 83.0 | 0.0% (ChatGPT + Perplexity + Google AI Overview) | 83.0 | high against none: differ |
Foglift: Free AI Brand Visibility Checker, brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | Good (not a visibility measurement) | not a visibility measurement | 88.0% (Perplexity) | not a visibility measurement | |
| Otterly | Good (not a visibility measurement) | not a visibility measurement | 47.8% (Perplexity) | not a visibility measurement | |
| Ahrefs | Good (not a visibility measurement) | not a visibility measurement | 67.0% (Perplexity) | not a visibility measurement | |
| Profound | Good (not a visibility measurement) | not a visibility measurement | 40.3% (Perplexity) | not a visibility measurement | |
| Peec AI | Good (not a visibility measurement) | not a visibility measurement | 34.0% (Perplexity) | not a visibility measurement | |
| SEO Informatica | Good (not a visibility measurement) | not a visibility measurement | 0.0% (Perplexity) | not a visibility measurement |
Cituna: AI visibility checker (crawler readiness), brand by brand
| Brand | What the checker reported | Its value, 0 to 100 | Our measured rate | Gap | Bands |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Semrush | Crawler-ready. Every check passed. Engines can reach you, read you and parse what you are. | none | 80.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity + Google AI Overview) | high against high: match | |
| Otterly | Engines can reach you, with gaps. Nothing blocks a crawler outright, but signals are missing that decide whether you get quoted rather than merely read. | none | 51.7% (ChatGPT + Perplexity + Google AI Overview) | medium against high: differ | |
| Ahrefs | Crawler-ready. Every check passed. Engines can reach you, read you and parse what you are. | none | 62.4% (ChatGPT + Perplexity + Google AI Overview) | high against high: match | |
| Profound | Engines can reach you, with gaps. Nothing blocks a crawler outright, but signals are missing that decide whether you get quoted rather than merely read. | none | 49.6% (ChatGPT + Perplexity + Google AI Overview) | medium against medium: match | |
| Peec AI | Engines can reach you, with gaps. Nothing blocks a crawler outright, but signals are missing that decide whether you get quoted rather than merely read. | none | 38.7% (ChatGPT + Perplexity + Google AI Overview) | medium against medium: match | |
| SEO Informatica | Crawler-ready. Every check passed. Engines can reach you, read you and parse what you are. | none | 0.0% (ChatGPT + Perplexity + Google AI Overview) | high against none: differ |
How we compared them.
The same tests for every checker. A test is left out when a checker gave too little to judge it.
- Measured rate: the mean of our measured mention rates on the engines the checker names that match our four surfaces, or of all four when none match.
- Bands: high, 50 or more; medium, 20 to 49; low, 1 to 19; none, under 1. A band matches when the checker's value and our measured rate fall in the same band.
- Order test: the checker puts the brands in the same order as our measured rates: a rank correlation (Spearman) of 0.7 or more, judged when at least 4 brands have a value.
- Control test: the control, SEO Informatica, which none of our answers named, comes out low: under 20 of 100, the lowest count, or a low or none band.
- Size test: the mean gap between the checker and our measured rate is 20 points or less.
- Verdict: agrees: every test that applied was passed; partly agrees: at least one passed; disagrees: none passed; too few results to judge: fewer than two tests applied.
- Control verdict: when the control is not low: a mistake if half or more of the prompts the checker showed for the control were about AI SEO or AI visibility tools, a different category if fewer, unverifiable if it showed none.
The self-naming rule.
A prompt that contains the brand being scored, such as asking what the brand is, is self-naming: an answer to it will talk about the brand, so it cannot show whether buyers see the brand. 29 of the 667 prompts the checkers showed were self-naming. Where a checker showed each prompt with its own result, we removed those prompts and worked its score out again; where every prompt was self-naming, its result reads not a visibility measurement.
| Checker | Brand scored | The prompt, as the checker showed it |
|---|---|---|
| Trakkr | Semrush | “is Semrush worth it for a small marketing team” |
| Trakkr | SEO Informatica | “is SEO Informatica worth it” |
| Trakkr | Peec AI | “is Peec AI worth it” |
| Trakkr | Ahrefs | “is Ahrefs worth it compared to Semrush” |
| Trakkr | Otterly | “What is Otterly.ai? What does it do?” |
| Trakkr | Otterly | “is Otterly.ai worth it for AI search monitoring” |
| Trakkr | Profound | “alternatives to Profound for AI search visibility” |
| Gauge | Semrush | “semrush” |
| Gauge | Peec AI | “peec” |
| MaxAEO | Peec AI | “peec ai funding” |
| MaxAEO | Peec AI | “peec ai review” |
| MaxAEO | Peec AI | “peec ai reviews” |
| MaxAEO | Peec AI | “peec ai vs profound” |
| MaxAEO | Peec AI | “what is peec ai” |
| MaxAEO | Peec AI | “peec ai valuation” |
| MaxAEO | Profound | “profound ai” |
| MaxAEO | Profound | “profound company” |
| Foglift | Semrush | “What is Semrush?” |
| Foglift | SEO Informatica | “What is Seoinformatica?” |
| Foglift | Peec AI | “What is Peec AI?” |
| Foglift | Ahrefs | “What is Ahrefs?” |
| Foglift | Otterly | “What is Otterly?” |
| Foglift | Profound | “What is Profound?” |
| Beamtrace | Semrush | “Is Semrush trusted by SEO professionals?” |
| Beamtrace | SEO Informatica | “What do clients say about SEO Informatica?” |
| Beamtrace | Peec AI | “Is Peec AI trusted by marketing teams?” |
| Beamtrace | Ahrefs | “Is Ahrefs known for reliable SEO data?” |
| Beamtrace | Otterly | “Is OtterlyAI trusted by marketing teams?” |
| Beamtrace | Profound | “Is Profound trusted by enterprise marketers?” |
The ones we could not verify.
When a checker rated the control well, the prompts it showed for the control decide what that means. These showed no prompts, or asked about something else, so their result for the control cannot be checked.
- Otterly (AI Authority Checker): gave the control 23 and showed no prompts, so we cannot tell what it asked. Verdict on the other tests: partly agrees with the measured rates.
- HubSpot (AI Search Grader): gave the control 42 and showed no prompts, so we cannot tell what it asked. Verdict on the other tests: partly agrees with the measured rates.
- Botric (Free GEO Audit (AI Visibility Score)): gave the control 83 and showed no prompts, so we cannot tell what it asked. Verdict on the other tests: disagrees with the measured rates.
- Bloomiro (Free Website Visibility Checker): gave the control 83 and showed no prompts, so we cannot tell what it asked. Verdict on the other tests: disagrees with the measured rates.
- Cituna (AI visibility checker (crawler readiness)): gave the control high and showed no prompts, so we cannot tell what it asked. Verdict on the other tests: too few results to judge.
- Beamtrace (Check AI Visibility for Free (homepage)): gave the control 20; the prompts it showed for the control were about a different category, not AI SEO tools.
The ones that gave no result, and the ones we did not try.
We never work around a check that asks for a person, an email address or an account. These checkers gave no result or were not tried; a person can still run them by hand.
Tried, but stopped at a check that asks a person to prove they are human (8): Semrush (AI Search Visibility Checker), Ahrefs (AI Visibility Checker (Brand Radar)), Indexly (AI Search Visibility Checker), OpenLens (See what AI says (homepage preview)), VisibilityTool.ai (Check my website (free ChatGPT check)), Searcherries (Free AI Visibility Checker), SEOJuice (Free AI Visibility Checker) and Parse.gl (Check your brand).
Tried, but asked for an email address (4): Searchable (Prompt Universe free report), Wellows (ChatGPT Visibility Tracker), Conductor (Free AI Visibility Report) and Brandi AI (Free AI Visibility Audit for Your Website).
Tried, but needed an account (2): Promptwatch (Free AI Visibility Report) and Gumshoe (Run a free audit (Visibility Audit free sample)).
Tried, but gave no usable result: Goodie (AI Visibility Index brand check): no result shown, Similarweb (AI Visibility Leaderboard): no result: its free limit was reached, Knowatoa (What's Chrome Saying? and homepage site check): no result shown and Sonarvue (AI Answer Checker): no result: it returned an error.
Found but not tried, because they ask for an email or an account (44): Profound (Free AEO Report), AthenaHQ (AI Search Performance Report (free AI visibility report)), AthenaHQ (Get Free Audit (10m)), Searchable (Free AI Visibility Report), Searchable (UCP Readiness Score (Agent Shopping Audit / AI Shopping Agent Checker)), Semrush (AI Overviews Visibility Checker), Gumshoe (Free sample audit (Run a free audit)), Gumshoe (Free sample AI Visibility Audit ('Run a free audit')), KIME (AI Web Health free audit), Wellows (Perplexity Visibility Tracker), Wellows (AI Overviews Tracker), Wellows (AI Visibility Report (free, white-label for agencies)), Wellows (Competitor Analysis on LLMs), Wellows (Technical SEO & LLM Visibility Audit), AI Peekaboo (Free AI Visibility Report (Free AI visibility checker)), Similarweb (AI Brand Visibility 'Get insights' search box), Brandlight (Brand-Specific AI Visibility Audit (application form)), Waikay (Free Brand Report (free plan, 3 credits)), RankPrompt (AI Visibility Audit (first report free)), GetCito (Free AI Visibility Audit (homepage button)), GetCito (Free AI Visibility Audit / AI Visibility Checker), MaxAEO (Free ChatGPT Visibility Checker), MaxAEO (Free Perplexity Visibility Checker), MaxAEO (Free Gemini Visibility Checker), MaxAEO (Free Claude Visibility Checker), Indexly (AI Brand Audit Report), Indexly (Free ChatGPT Visibility Report (AI Visibility Report)), Indexly (AI Readiness Audit), Sanbi (Free AI Visibility Audit / Report), LLM Pulse (Free AI Visibility & Reputation Report (also Brand Mention Checker at /brand-mention-checker and AEO Grader at /aeo-grader)), LLM Pulse (Free AEO Grader), LLM Pulse (Free AI Brand Mention Checker), LLM Pulse (AI Discoverability & Authority Checker), LLM Pulse (AI Content Readiness Checker), RivalScope (Check Your AI Visibility (free preview)), RivalScope (Check Your AI Visibility (Free)), Am I on AI (AI Visibility Checker (Free Preview); same form on homepage), Am I on AI (AI Visibility Audit (Free)), LLMrefs (Homepage keyword search (hero form)), SEO.com AI Overview Checker (AI Overview Checker), SEO.com AI Overview Checker (Website Traffic Checker (with AI Visibility Score)), Beamtrace (AI Prompt Research Tool), PromptRush (Free AI Visibility Checker) and Mentionova (Free AI visibility report).
Found but not tried, because they are a second tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried, or they check a page rather than a brand (74)
- Otterly: GEO Content Check (GEO Content Checker), checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Scrunch: Agent Grader (AI Readiness Analyzer), checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Scrunch: AI visibility audit (Run AI visibility audit), another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Goodie: Free brand check (AI Visibility Index), checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Goodie: Agent Site Audit (Free Agent Readiness Audit), checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Promptwatch: AI SEO Audit, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Searchable: ChatGPT Product Visibility Checker, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- SE Ranking: Answer Engine Optimization Checker (AEO Checker), checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- SE Ranking: Free AI Overviews Tracker check ('Check 5 keywords for free'), another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- SE Ranking: ChatGPT Location Changer, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Semrush: AI Traffic Checker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Ahrefs: Free Google AI Mode Tracker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Ahrefs: Free Google AI Overviews Tracker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Trakkr: AI Site Grader, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Trakkr: AEO Checker, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Trakkr: ChatGPT Ads Context Hints, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Wellows: How AI Sees Your Brand, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Wellows: Prompt Audit (free prompt difficulty checker), another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Wellows: AI Citation Readiness Checker, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- AI Peekaboo: Google AI Overview Checker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- AI Peekaboo: AI Sentiment Checker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- AI Peekaboo: AI Visibility Gap Analyzer, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- AI Peekaboo: Legal AI Visibility Check (for law firms), another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- AI Peekaboo: AI Client Brief for Agencies, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- AI Peekaboo: Product Visibility Checker, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Similarweb: AI Traffic Checker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Knowatoa: 'See where my site stands' homepage form, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- RankPrompt: Free ChatGPT Rank Checker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- RankPrompt: Free AEO Checker (AI readiness score), checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Geoptie: Free GEO Rank Tracker (AI rank tracker), another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Geoptie: Free ChatGPT Rank Tracker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Geoptie: Free Perplexity Rank Tracker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Geoptie: Free Claude Rank Tracker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Geoptie: Free AI Overviews Tracker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Geoptie: GEO Backlink Finder, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Geoptie: Free GEO Audit, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Geoptie: GEO Content Checker, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- MaxAEO: Free AI Visibility Checker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- MaxAEO: Free GEO Audit Tool, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- MaxAEO: Free AEO Checker, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Indexly: ChatGPT Visibility Checker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Indexly: Gemini Visibility Checker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Indexly: Grok Visibility Checker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Indexly: Perplexity Visibility Checker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Indexly: AI SEO Audit, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- GenRank: RAG Simulator (Retrieval Simulator), checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- GenRank: ChatGPT Ad Spy, could not be confirmed usable
- Foglift: Free Technical Audit for AI Readiness (AI Readiness website grader), checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Foglift: Free AI search readiness checker, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Foglift: Free AEO & GEO checker for AI visibility, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Foglift: Free AEO checker for AI citation readiness, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Foglift: Content GEO Optimizer (Content AI Readiness Optimizer), checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Sonarvue: Free AI visibility checker (AI-readiness grade), checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Sonarvue: Answer-Engine Audit, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- CitedSpy: LLM Visibility Tracker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- CitedSpy: AI Visibility Score, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- CitedSpy: LLM Visibility Score, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- CitedSpy: AI Brand Visibility Score, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- CitedSpy: AI Search Visibility Audit, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- CitedSpy: GEO Checker, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- CitedSpy: AEO Checker, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- CitedSpy: AI Answer Checker, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- CitedSpy: AI Search Citation Checker (AI Search Result Checker), checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- CitedSpy: AI Brand Mention Checker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- CitedSpy: "Am I in AI Search?" Instant Report, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- CitedSpy: ChatGPT Rank Tracker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- CitedSpy: ChatGPT Citation Tracker, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- CitedSpy: ChatGPT Brand Mention Monitor, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- SEOJuice: GEO Content Analyzer, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- SEOJuice: Live SERP Checker by Country & Language, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Parse.gl: Free brand check / brand search (public brand pages); 'Check your brand' at https://parse.gl/check, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Mentionable: Free ChatGPT Sources Finder, another tool from a vendor whose main checker we tried
- Mentionable: Free GEO Audit Tool, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
- Mentionova: AI Visibility Diagnostic, checks a page, content or query, not a brand
Clear mistakes a checker made.
These checkers got a brand plainly wrong. Each one is logged with the screenshot that shows it.
Trakkr
- What it reported
- Free AI Rank Tracker, 16 October 2026, run on otterly.ai: Otterly named in 0 of 8 buyer questions. Asked "What is Otterly.ai? What does it do?", its model (an OpenAI model with web search off) described Otterly.ai as an AI transcription and note-taking service and listed Otter.ai, Rev and Sonix, so it confused Otterly with Otter.ai.
- What we measured
- Otterly was named in 462 of 750 ChatGPT answers (62%), 191 of 400 Perplexity answers (48%), 11 of 24 Google AI Overviews (46%) and 12 of 25 Google AI Mode answers (48%) to our 25 buyer questions on 16 October 2026, and otterly.ai was cited in 444 of the 750 ChatGPT answers (59%). Otterly is an AI search visibility tracker, not a transcription app.
SE Ranking
- What it reported
- Free AI visibility check, 16 October 2026, run on otterly.ai: 0 brand mentions in AI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, while the same table shows linked mentions of otterly.ai (82 AI Overviews, 6 AI Mode, 11 ChatGPT, 1 Gemini, 0 Perplexity), so its database does not match the brand name Otterly.
- What we measured
- Otterly was named in 462 of 750 ChatGPT answers (62%), 191 of 400 Perplexity answers (48%), 11 of 24 Google AI Overviews (46%) and 12 of 25 Google AI Mode answers (48%) to our 25 buyer questions on 16 October 2026, and otterly.ai was cited in 444 of the 750 ChatGPT answers (59%).
The evidence.
Screenshots from our runs, with their metadata removed. Select one to open it full size.
The Clarity Audit
Want to know who AI names in your market?
The Clarity Audit is free. We look at your website and your market, show which businesses Google and AI answers name for the searches your buyers make, and list the three fixes to consider first. No call needed.